Our own private Afghanistan
Police look the other way as guns, Molotov cocktails and vandalism mark the last weeks of Cudahy’s campaign season
By Jeffrey Anderson & Matthew Fleischer
The images are grainy, but surveillance video from the night of October 26, 2008, is clear enough to show a hooded thug run up to the home of Cudahy City Council candidate Luis Garcia and hurl a brick at his front window. Seconds later, Garcia emerges from his house in a full sprint, clad only in his underwear, chasing after the assailant.
In the last 18 months, police reports show unknown assailants have launched a half dozen similar attacks on his house and property – including a Molotov cocktail assault that scorched the front end of his truck just feet from his home.
No one has ever been caught in connection with the crimes. But this much is clear: Someone doesn’t want Garcia to run for Cudahy City Council.
On March 3, the 1.2-square mile city in southeast L.A. County will hold just its second election in 10 years. The last election, in 2007, ended in a razor-thin, 33-vote defeat for Garcia and his running mate Daniel Cota, amidst allegations of electioneering and gang influence at the polls. That same election saw challenger Tony Mendoza drop out of the race after receiving telephone death threats.
Since then, Cudahy’s anemic democracy has only deteriorated. Earlier this month, police say, Cudahy Councilwoman Rosa Diaz first said she wouldn’t run for reelection, then decided she would – and then found her security camera disabled and the window of her townhouse shot with a pellet gun while she was home.
Diaz was a first-time victim. Since 2006, Garcia’s truck has been splattered with paint four times. Last July, an unknown assailant threw a brick through his front window. Two weeks later, the Molotov cocktail assault was caught on a surveillance camera. A vehicle belonging to Garcia’s running mate Daniel Cota was spray-painted.
Mendoza, Garcia, Cota and Diaz all have two things in common: they ran for city council, and subsequently became targets of vandalism and terrorization. Police reports show that Garcia got a license plate of a getaway vehicle in the October brick attack, yet, so far, Maywood police have failed to make a single arrest in any of the dozen or so attacks on Cudahy candidates.
“You could draw a pattern here,” admits Maywood Police Chief Frank Hauptmann, whose department polices Cudahy on a $2 million per year contract. “Maybe there’s a common motive.”
Yet Maywood police have not identified any suspects, and Hauptmann implies they have stopped investigating: “Without further evidence, we can’t conclude that it’s the same individual or different individuals who are responsible. We don’t want to point fingers.”
Hauptmann’s situation is precarious. The FBI is investigating corruption in Cudahy, according to veteran law enforcement sources and the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office. Maywood police have been under state and federal investigation since 2006 for allegations of brutality and receiving kickbacks from a tow truck company. Yet Hauptmann denies knowledge of either investigation. “I don’t believe [the feds] would inform me unless they thought I should know,” he said, in an interview with City Beat last August.
With the 2009 Cudahy City Council election less than a week away, a treacherous situation is unfolding only 10 miles away from downtown Los Angeles – one that is simply unimaginable in small, wealthy cities like Beverly Hills or West Hollywood. Authorities appear unwilling or incapable of guaranteeing a fair, safe election.
In the mid-20th century, a rancher named Michael Cudahy founded the city he named after himself, and mapped out a series of deep, narrow lots that allowed for small farms. As agriculture and the subsequent automobile industry came and went, the demographics shifted and Cudahy became a city of working-class immigrants, many of them undocumented. It has a population of 26,000, with a scant 4,500 registered voters and just 1,000 actual voters. It also has a dark side that is easily concealed in the rundown houses and apartment complexes that have since filled the city’s deep lots.
A review of crime reports and news accounts over the past 30 years and interviews with law enforcers and numerous longtime residents suggests that contemporary Cudahy is a narco-hub – a haven for gangs and mid-level drug mules.
In the 1980s, major arrests were frequent: A 1986 drug bust in Dallas, Texas, involving a Mexican national from Cudahy, netted the largest amount of Mexican “black tar” heroin ever seized in the U.S. Two years later, police seized $2.4 million worth of cocaine from two Cudahy homes. In 1989, a Cudahy man was caught with 288 pounds of cocaine in the trunk of his car; that same year, a drug task force seized more than 400 pounds of cocaine at a Cudahy house on Clara Street.
During the 1990s and early 2000s, suspects from Cudahy branched out across the United States. A Santa Ana undercover narcotics team seized 154 pounds of cocaine in 1993, and again, one of the suspects was from Cudahy. In 1998, law enforcers made a “significant dent” in the cocaine and heroin supply in Utah, when they arrested suspects in Cudahy and Salt Lake City. One of Ohio’s largest drug recoveries of 2002 (44 pounds of cocaine) involved a Cudahy man. In 2003, a brazen daytime abduction reminiscent of the tactics of a Mexican drug cartel resulted in the body of a Cudahy man turning up in an industrial area near Watts.
Throughout the 1990s, the L.A. County Sheriff had a contract to police Cudahy. But in 2000, Cudahy’s fortunes changed. Then-City Councilman George Perez stepped aside and was immediately installed as City Manager, in a move that sparked a grand jury investigation by District Attorney Steve Cooley into an alleged conflict of interest. No charges resulted, and since then, Perez, a former janitor who has since amassed significant real estate holdings, has ruled Cudahy with an iron fist. In 2003, he fired the Sheriff and hired Maywood P.D., a force with a reputation for hiring problem officers and for suspected internal corruption.
In 2007, Cudahy was off to a violent start with a number of homicides, including two men executed in broad daylight in front of the Elizabeth Learning Center. A Maywood detective who spoke to fifth graders at Park Avenue Elementary, near Cudahy City Hall, said 50 percent of the kids reported seeing guns in their homes, and 30 percent reported seeing drugs or paraphernalia.
Though killings tapered off in 2008, a dispute between the dominant 18th Street Gang and newer sets Down in Action (DIA) and Just Blazin’ It (JBI) have added to a complicated landscape that already included Florencia 13 and Cudahy 13. A neighboring gang from the troubled city of Bell Gardens known as Kansas Street also has been associated with violence in Cudahy. According to law enforcers, the Mexican Mafia makes its presence felt through these gangs.
Yet despite the crime, police seem
to make residents feel more anxious than safe.
“Officer Lawrence Mesa is probably the most popular traffic cop you will ever see,” boasts an article on the city of Cudahy’s website. More like “infamous.” Around Cudahy, people call him “El Moto.” At a recent city council meeting, a woman who had recently been pulled over by Mesa got up to angrily denounce the officer for unfairly targeting Latinos in traffic stops. She accused him of hunting for undocumented residents so he could impound their cars and generate revenue for the city.
Alfredo Leal, 25, an Army veteran only two months back from Iraq, says he’s already been pulled over several times by Mesa since returning home – and has never been charged with a moving violation. “He can’t touch me, because I have a military ID,” says Leal. “But he towed my mom’s car.”
Hauptmann acknowledges Mesa’s predilection for aggressive traffic stops, and recently advised him to mount a surveillance camera on his motorcycle. But the discretion to turn the camera on lies with Mesa, and Hauptmann says the primary intent is to protect Mesa from frivolous or unfounded complaints.
Democracy’s last best hope in Cudahy may be the upcoming election. But District Attorney Steve Cooley has denied any jurisdiction over election matters, including detailed allegations, reviewed by City Beat, of criminal threats made against Mendoza in 2006 and of election tampering in 2007. D.A. spokeswoman Sandi Gibbons says Cudahy is a matter for the FBI.
On a recent Saturday, City Beat observed what appeared to be city resources being used for campaign activity: signs endorsing Mayor David Silva and City Planning Commissioner Josue Barrios were stacked in a city vehicle parked outside the home of a city employee, Gerardo Vallejo – a two-time felon and right-hand man to City Manager George Perez. Another vehicle with campaign signs was parked behind City Hall next to a black Ford Mustang that Perez and Vallejo use to actively campaign for Silva and Barrios. Later that day, the same Mustang was spotted in the parking lot of grocery store owner and city councilman Osvaldo Conde – right next to the same black 1999 Jeep Cherokee that Garcia says he spotted leaving the scene of the October attack.
Deputy District Attorney David Demerjian, head of the office’s public integrity unit, acknowledges that city resources being used for campaign purposes is illegal, but refers to the specific observations in Cudahy as “minimal and incidental.”
L.A. County election officials and
the state Fair Political Practices Committee have not responded to requests for information about election monitoring protocols.
Garcia says March 3 can’t come fast enough, but despite the threats he isn’t backing down.
“This is America,” he says. “The people of Cudahy deserve to feel safe in their own city.”
Published: 02/25/2009
DIGG | del.icio.us | REDDIT
Other Stories by Jeffrey Anderson
Other Stories by Matthew Fleischer
Related Articles
Comments
Anyone with half a brain who lives in Cudahy doesn't find this article too difficult to believe. NewsWatchDog, you need to do more homework and perhaps actually visit Cudahy and see what's going on for yourself. From your comments, I can assume you either don't live in our City, or you don't have at least half a brain. I can't believe you feel a blog site is the height of worthwhile news. Blogs offer only opinion and these reporters offer first-hand accounts. Let me guess, do you frequent grocery store check out stands for glimpses of the Globe and Enquirer to "catch up" on World news? Your objectivity on this matter is beyond questionable. The only thing obvious about your rant is your high regard for the incumbents and the corrupt machine they operate in Cudahy.
In either event, I'm glad to see this article written. It's the courage of writers like Mr. Anderson and Mr. Fleischer that shed light on issues and activities that are all too often overlooked. It takes courage to take a stand against a machine that has gained strength by making others feel helpless.
You can make whatever unfounded allegations you want to in regard the reporters or the candidates running against the incumbents, but your allegations make you sound nuttier than your belief that all of these documented events are false.
I applaud the effort of anyone willing to stand up for the voiceless and champion a vision that is in stark contrast to a dark world of corruption and crime. GO COTA AND GARCIA!!! YOU HAVE MY VOTE AND THE VOTE OF CONCERNED CITIZENS OF CUDAHY!!! SUERTE!!!
Well Sergio, it appears that half a brain is needed for you. A full brain sees a city trying to help it's citizens.
If you really did live in Cudahy, his week alone you would have seen (1) a new park open for residents so that anyone in the city can walk to a park within 10 minutes, (2) a safety fair that was great if it wasn't for Garcia and company trying to disrupt residents from getting helpful information and (3) a citizenship fair.
While blogs aren't the height of journalism, that blog certainly points out how Garcia is manipulating media like Anderson and Fleischer.
And where is Anderson's investigation of Garcia and Cota? There are police reports on them 5 times since October 2008, including threat to commit assault, assault with a moving vehicle and ... this is no surprise to anyone who has met Garcia, disruption of public events.
I live in Cudahy, and I don't find anything that Cota and Garcia say as credible.
They both worked in the city and were investigated for stealing...if they didn't quit, they would have been fired.
Why is it that every election these two losers make false claims and dumb Westside reporters fall for their false claims of harassment? Can’t you see that you are being used by them?
Check it out. They always have cars conveniently parked in front. They are always older cars that they don’t use. They always call the press immediately after they file a police report. They always make claims to the press that it’s political but somehow don’t say that to police.
And recently, they had a video camera capture the action. But if you watch it, you can see that the person who committed the act seems to magically know where to stand out of camera range. Then magically you see Cota and Garcia both pull up in a van just a minute after the incident only moments away from “capturing the culprits.” Garcia said to reporters that he was at home and came out of his house. His own camera shows that’s a lie.
It’s all too convenient if you ask me.
Stop giving them coverage and watch how fast the “harassment” will stop.
Yesterday, Mr. Anderson was seen hopping from voting location to voting location. Sadly he was spending time interviewing Rosa Diaz's son and Luis Garcia ONLY. I saw him at Lugo Park standing with Garcia for over 40 minutes in the parking lot.
Why such obvious bias? Is this a reflection on your writing?
Mr. Anderson seems to have taken sides long ago (just look at his past work for the LA Weekly) and configures anecdotal information in such ways as to "prove" his conclusions. But never ever offers real hard evidence.
Those of us in Cudahy who voted yesterday for the right change simply ask that CityBeat give us fair and accurate, non-biased non-inflammatory reporting if you must report on us.
I guess the fact that our city residents prefer Spanish and never really see the CityBeat is of no consequence to you. Although second and third generation Cudahy residents like myself are aware of CityBeat, do not think we appreciate your coverage making us out to be ignorant Latinos in need of your "wisdom."
Do your readers, us, and yourselves a favor...report on things that matter to your readership and not perpetuate a stereotype that we "ignorant Latinos" can't run our city or resort to violence at election time. Not to mention the stereotype that you smart Anglos in Los Angeles are much more enlightened than we are when it comes to politics. Look at yourselves before you look at us.
Perhaps the nastiest thing of all is how Luis Garcia, Daniel Cota and now Rosa Diaz use these stereotypes to their selfish advantage. Their agenda is to get power. It doesn't seem to matter to them how much they hurt our community by exploiting perceptions of Latinos and "boogyman" issues like immigration for their political advantage.
Mr. Anderson, ask yourself why Diaz, Garcia and Cota came up with a last-minute issue regarding one traffic officer who is doing his job, making our streets safe from violators? Diaz was on the council for 6 years and NEVER said a word. Only in a desperate attempt to get elected does she bring it up, and the others too.
I've met this officer at our Town Hall meetings. He is a young Latino and veteran who believes in upholding the law. Diaz, Garcia and Cota are so disgusting, they are actually telling people he is racist.
Mr. Anderson, why don't you report on how Diaz, Garcia, and Cota have flagrantly violated the law by refusing to file their contribution reports? No, I guess that doesn't fit with your "David vs. Goliath" myth.
Stop being used by these self-serving gadflys and stop using Cudahy as your target.
Be that as it may Hernandez. I've lived in Cudahy my whole life and since the ousting of LA Country Sheriff I have seen cars stolen on my block, gangmembers selling dope to kids, and people being killed in front of the vice mayor's house. A few parks can't get rid of the fact that more people are being victims of crime in the city of Cudahy.
I have lived in Cudahy my whole life and the violence gets worse everyday. Of course we know who Hernandez voted for but he does not realize that this city needs a change. With the same people running the election it only gives me a reason to believe that they are behind something trickey and they do not want no one to know what really goes on in the city.
Nothing will change in this city it has not happend before and it wont happend now. It's time they actually step up and do something about it. Before an innocent bystander gets killed. Hopefully these men will do something for our city.
Oh yeah Hernandez quit being so DEFENSIVE it's not like you were running for election.
It's slow, but I see this place changing for the better. I've been to the events for citizenship, the health fairs and the financial advice event. When I see some of these posts I think people would rather hate than participate.
I've lived in HP and the Gardens before moving here and anyone complaining about "violence" cant be serious that Garcia and Cota are the answer. Look at that cocktail "security video", obviously they staged that fire. Look at the picture of the paint. everyone who knows him thinks that is paint from his day job. he's fooled the media, but they haven't looked to closely at him yet.
I agree, you gotta be aware. but compared to the others on the river, we're good. You're fooling if you think locals can change gangs. Villaraigosa hired all those cops and ask co central if they think its better. If there's meth and coke, then there's gangs no matter what. Besides, I think it was worse with the sheriffs, they thought they were bigger than us.
Election day is over, it's time for us all to stop dividing and get involved in positive community activity like helping at the schools or ESL classes, rather than complaining. Change starts with us.
Ridiculous. The guys that think there isn't corruption in Cudahy seemed to forget a few names, I.E. George Perez, the city manager/mastermind of dirty politics, and who could forget George Cole, former Bell Councilman that somehow still pulls all the strings in the southeast with the help from his friend John Noguez in H.P.? What about the scandals involving Maywood Towing Company and the investigation into Maywood Police abuse and racial profiling (maywood PD serves Cudahy as well, remember?) No corruption? Think again.
Shame on Anderson's editors and those who believe his stories without checking facts.
Although Anderson is trying to get paid a second time for writing essentially the same story he wrote for the LA Weekly, this is particularly shoddy "reporting." Nothing even approaches an effort to have objective reporting.
As NBC 4 reported, it seems likely that Garcia staged these stunts himself. I'm more inclined to believe the analysis at http://southeastcities.blogspot.com.
I think Anderson is either (1) being used by Garcia and Cota to help them in the election, or (2) he is a willing participant. Either way, it's reporting at its worst.
Certainly anyone who is objective would question Garcia, Cota and Diaz' motives for pushing forward these stories of vandalism that oddly have not occurred in any arrests.